Godolphin Finney Burslem

In the long and distinguished history of the Burslem family—a lineage populated by decorated colonels and stoic vicars—there stands one figure who defies every convention of Victorian morality. Godolphin Finney Burslem (1855–After 1910) was a man of a thousand aliases, a hero by some accounts and a scoundrel by all others. A one-legged veteran of the Zulu Wars who reinvented himself as a "Society Lion" in New York and a "Gentleman" in London, his life was a high-stakes performance of charm, fraud, and breathtaking audacity.

The Gunner’s Beginning: From Portsea to Zululand

Godolphin was born in Portsea, Hampshire, around June 1855, the son of the embattled Captain George James Burslem and Angelina Ellen Stephens. His life of improvisation began early; at age fifteen, he lied about his age to enlist as a driver in the Royal Artillery on May 5, 1871.

His early military record was far from glorious. While serving in Cape Town in 1874, he was arrested for desertion and subsequently imprisoned. However, the battlefield provided him with the scars—and the stories—that would become his lifelong currency. He saw action in the Kaffir Wars and the Zulu War. During the Battle of Kambula Hill, his military career came to a violent end when a gun carriage upset, crushing his left leg. The limb was amputated, and Godolphin was eventually discharged as a gunner with a pension of one shilling a day.

The West Point Sensation: A "Captain" in New York

By 1881, the lowly gunner had undergone a metamorphosis. He arrived in America as "Captain James G. Burslem," a dashing veteran who claimed to have been with the Prince Imperial of France when he fell in Zululand. He took New York society by storm, armed with letters of introduction to President Garfield and a wardrobe of unofficial uniforms.

His tenure at the Cranston’s Hotel in West Point was a whirlwind of vulgarity and charm. He was accused of insulting guests—notably referring to a young lady as a "Zulu with succotash eyes"—and acting as a "cowardly rough." The scandal reached its peak when a Miss Scoofy of San Francisco, incensed by his rudeness, broke a bamboo cane over his head on the hotel veranda. Burslem made no resistance, while his fiancée, Miss Barclay, threatened to kill his assailant.

The London Crimes: The "Honorable" Imposter

Following the exposure of his claims in America, Burslem returned to London, where his ambitions shifted toward large-scale fraud. Adopting the name The Hon. Captain Sydney Godolphin Osborne, he systematically plundered London’s tradesmen.

In 1885, he was charged with obtaining over £1,400 in jewellery from Mr. Keymer of Hanover Square, and £45 in harness from a saddler by claiming he resided at the fictional "Osborne Hall." His audacity knew no bounds; he even defrauded a relative, Thomas Burslem of Esher, by cashing a dividend warrant and pocketing the money.

The law finally tightened its grip in June 1885. During his trial at Bow Street, his own uncle, Major Rollo Burslem of Windsor Castle, was called to the stand to testify against him. The Major revealed that the "Honorable Captain" was merely his nephew, a runaway schoolboy and a discharged gunner. Godolphin was sentenced to five years’ penal servitude.

Wall Street and the "Representative Men"

After his release in 1889, Burslem fled once more to New York. By 1890, he was managing the Phoenix Club in Buffalo, but he soon set his sights on the financial capital of the world. In 1894, he was naturalized as a U.S. citizen, claiming to draw an $80 monthly pension for his "heroism" in Egypt and Africa—a massive embellishment of his cancelled one-shilling-a-day British pension.

By 1898, he was operating as a "promoter, banker, and broker" at 2 Wall Street. He successfully placed himself in the prestigious volume Representative Men of New York, a book where he essentially authored his own fictionalized biography, claiming to have incorporated companies with a total capitalization of $23,000,000.

A Literary Thief: "Crime and Criminals"

In 1895, in a move of peak irony, Burslem published a book titled "Crime and Criminals." While largely a plagiarized version of the Newgate Calendar, the final chapter contains a first-person account of a "Clerical Impostor" who swindled a London silversmith out of £5,000. The detail with which the author describes the "confidence trick"—involving a fake bishop and a silver dinner service—bears the distinct hallmark of Burslem’s own criminal methodology.

Final Acts and the 1910 Census

Burslem's later years remained litigious and chaotic. He was sued for divorce in 1899 by Mary Elizabeth Whiteway, who alleged he maintained a "fine establishment" in Cedarhurst while frequenting hotels with other women. In 1900, he was arrested again in New York for larceny involving stock fraud, and again in 1901 for stealing rent from a client.

He was last recorded in the 1910 Census living on West 115th Street in Manhattan, residing with his wife Mary and still listing his occupation as a "Broker." Godolphin Finney Burslem left behind a legacy of dishonoured bills, manufactured medals, and a story so improbable that it remains a masterclass in the art of the Victorian long con.

Fast Facts for Historical Reference